Local search study: Orange County chiropractors

How 46 practices actually show up on Google — an independent audit of every chiropractic practice we could identify in Newburgh and Middletown, New York. What's working, what's broken, and what it likely costs them.

Published by MEPS Digital · 2026 · No practice is identified individually.

One market of several. We measure local search across the Hudson Valley — home services, medical and professional practices — and publish the results industry by industry. Chiropractors are simply the first market written up in full; the same audit runs for plumbers, roofers, dentists and anyone else who depends on being found locally. Ask for yours.

The headline numbers

46
practices audited
39%
no website linked on Google
85%
few or no listing photos
87%
incomplete Google profile

Website fundamentals

These are the basics Google checks. The percentages below are calculated only over the 28 practices whose website actually loaded — the 18 practices with no website at all are excluded, so these figures are not inflated by businesses that simply have nothing to test.

Issue foundShareCount
No structured data (schema markup)50%14 of 28
Missing meta description46%13 of 28
Not mobile-friendly21%6 of 28
No HTTPS (browser shows "Not Secure")11%3 of 28

Structured data is what tells Google explicitly that you are a local business, in a particular town, offering particular services. Half of these practices give Google nothing to work with, which means Google has to infer it — and inference is where rankings get lost.

Page speed

Google treats mobile page experience as a ranking factor, and the large majority of local searches happen on a phone. Scores here come from Google's own PageSpeed Insights mobile performance test.

62
median mobile speed score, out of 100
22%
scored under 50, which is poor

Measured on the 27 sites that returned a score. A slow page does two things at once: it ranks lower, and the visitors who do arrive leave before the page finishes loading.

Google Business Profile completeness

The Google Business Profile — the Maps listing — is the most important local ranking asset and the cheapest to fix. We scored completeness across whether a website is linked, a phone number is present, hours are listed, photos are uploaded, reviews exist, and a primary category is set.

FindingShareCount
Profile not fully complete87%40 of 46
Few or no photos85%39 of 46
No website linked39%18 of 46

Median completeness across all 46 practices was 60%. Every item in that list is free to fix and takes an afternoon. This is the clearest finding in the study: the cheapest available improvements are the ones being skipped.

Reputation

Review volume and recency are among the strongest local ranking signals, and the clearest trust signal for a patient deciding between two practices.

14
reviews for the median practice
5.0
median star rating

The ratings are excellent almost everywhere — these are well-regarded practices. The gap between the median practice and the local leaders is not quality of care. It is review volume, and the fact that some practices ask for reviews systematically while most do not ask at all.

Review recency mattered as much as count. Several practices in the study had not received a new Google review in over three years, while others in the same towns were receiving them within the last month. A profile that has gone quiet reads, to a prospective patient scanning results, like a practice that has gone quiet.

Marketing maturity

Only 33% of the practices had any analytics installed on their website, detected from publicly visible tracking tags. Two thirds therefore have no way of knowing how many people visit their site, where those people came from, or whether anything they do about it works.

What we would tell a practice owner

Methodology

Sample: 46 chiropractic practices in Newburgh and Middletown, New York, identified through the Google Places API and filtered by Google's own business category so unrelated businesses were excluded. Duplicate listings for the same practice were removed where they were detectable.

Website checks were performed by requesting each practice's public homepage and inspecting the returned HTML for HTTPS, a mobile viewport tag, page title, meta description and structured data. Speed scores come from Google's PageSpeed Insights API on mobile. Profile completeness is derived from publicly available Google Places data.

Limitations: this is a point-in-time snapshot and practices may have made changes since collection. Only public homepage data was examined, so problems on deeper pages are not reflected here. Google's category data occasionally misclassifies a business. Review recency is estimated from a sample of recent reviews rather than a complete history. No private, paid, or login-protected data was accessed, and no individual practice is identified anywhere in this report.

On correlation: practices with more complete profiles do tend to have more reviews in this data. We are not claiming one causes the other — larger, established practices can afford both — and within this sample some signals showed no relationship to review count at all.

Want this run on your own practice?

We will send you the same one-page breakdown for your business, free, whether or not we ever work together.

Get your free audit